The Inn at Windmill Lane

23 Windmill Lane, Amagansett, NY, 11930 United States


From Andrew Harper

View Map

Lovely inn on two acres behind privet hedges in Amagansett, on the East End of Long Island. Main house with seven suites and three outlying cottages are done in classic Hamptons shingle style. Interior design is pleasingly simple: white wainscoting walls, dark pine floors with beige carpeting, and contemporary art. One suite had a woodburning fireplace, a separate small living room, and an expansive bath with a large shower. The three cottages are similarly well-appointed but offer even more privacy and space, and have their own exercise and steam rooms. A common room and fully equipped kitchen are available for guest use; the inn serves breakfast only. Several beautiful beaches are nearby, with coveted parking passes available.

From the Hideaway Report


September 2011 Hideaway Report

When we last visited The Hamptons on Long Island’s East End in spring 2009, The Reform Club had not yet opened, so on my most recent visit to New York, I made a point of retracing my steps. (I had assumed that the unusual name must indicate some connection with the venerable institution on London’s Pall Mall, but the hotel’s website inelegantly insists it is “because we want to encourage change during your visit with us.”) The property is located ...

Please log in to view the entire report »


Suite, from $900; Cottage, from $2,015.

These published rates, in US dollars, serve only as a guideline for travel planning and may vary based on season, currency exchange rates and other factors. The latest rates, including preferred Andrew Harper rates, are available to our subscribers booking online, directly with the hotels or through the Andrew Harper Travel Office. When booking direct, always provide your Andrew Harper subscriber number. Subscriber benefits are available only in conjunction with Andrew Harper rates.
Andrew Harper MemberReport Inappropriate Content



Beach Access
Fitness Center
Hair Dryer
iPod Docking Station/MP3 Player
Minibar with Refrigerator
Wireless Internet


Javascript is required to view this map.

request a rate

This property does not currently offer the ability to book online. Please contact us to request rates & availability.

Other Hotels and Partners